By Prof. Stéphane Narcis
Honorary President and Honorary QA Auditor
International Association for Quality Assurance in Pre-Tertiary & Higher Education (QAHE)
Disclosure: The author is affiliated with the International Association for Quality Assurance in Pre-tertiary and Higher Education (QAHE), an independent organisation that provides external quality evaluation and accreditation services to educational institutions, including fee-based services. The views expressed in this article are the author’s own, and the article is intended as an informational contribution rather than promotional content.
The expansion of online education and short professional training courses has given learners more options than ever before. Across many countries, working adults and recent graduates can now enrol in programmes offered by institutions based locally or abroad without leaving their jobs or home countries. While this flexibility is valuable, it has also made it harder for students and their families to judge which programmes are credible and which are not. Quality assurance provides a practical way to reduce that uncertainty.
A programme that has undergone external quality review is more likely to have clear learning outcomes, qualified teaching staff, adequate student support, and fair assessment methods. These elements matter because a certificate or degree is only useful if employers, professional bodies, or further-education institutions recognise the knowledge and skills it represents. When quality assurance is weak or absent, learners risk spending time and money on programmes whose awards carry little weight in the labour market.
Verify claims, not slogans
In practice, students should look for specific and verifiable information rather than general claims. Marketing materials that simply state a programme is “internationally recognised” or “globally accredited” are not sufficient. A credible provider should name the quality assurance or accreditation body involved, indicate whether the review covers the institution or individual programmes, and show that the status is current. Students can then check that information on the website of the named body or with the relevant national authority in the country where the institution is based.
Start with national authorities
National quality assurance agencies and ministries remain the most important reference points. Many countries publish lists of licensed institutions and accredited programmes. Checking whether a provider appears on the official list of the ministry of higher education or the national quality assurance agency is one of the simplest and most reliable steps a prospective student can take. For programmes offered across borders, it is also useful to confirm whether the qualification is likely to be recognised for employment or further study in the student’s own country before enrolment — a point that matters particularly for Indonesian learners, as discussed below.
What Indonesian learners should know
For readers in Indonesia, several national regulations and services are directly relevant when evaluating both domestic and foreign programmes.
Diplomas and certificates. Ministerial Regulation No. 50 of 2024 concerning diplomas, competency certificates and professional certificates in higher education governs how these awards are issued and what they signify. Understanding the differences between an academic diploma (ijazah), a competency certificate, and a professional certificate helps learners judge what a particular programme will actually confer.
National accreditation. Higher education institutions and study programmes in Indonesia are accredited through the national accreditation system involving the National Accreditation Board for Higher Education (BAN-PT or Badan Akreditasi Nasional Perguruan Tinggi) and Independent Accreditation Agencies (LAM or Lembaga Akreditasi Mandiri), according to their respective responsibilities. BAN-PT is responsible for institutional accreditation and the national accreditation framework, while LAM conducts study programme accreditation within its recognised scope. Where a study programme is not covered by an LAM, accreditation may be handled by BAN-PT in accordance with applicable regulations. Prospective students should check the accreditation status of both an institution and its study programme through the relevant official channels before enrolling.
Recognition of foreign qualifications. For Indonesians considering degrees or other higher education qualifications from foreign institutions — including online and distance-learning providers — it is important to understand the applicable recognition and equivalency requirements before enrolment. Ministerial Regulation No. 50 of 2024 addresses diplomas and learning documents obtained through foreign higher education systems. Under Article 23, foreign diplomas or learning documents intended to support further study within Indonesia’s national higher education system are subject to an equivalency process carried out by the receiving Indonesian university in accordance with guidance provided by the Ministry.
Students planning to continue their education in Indonesia should therefore consult their intended university about the applicable equivalency requirements and procedures before enrolling in a foreign programme. For employment, professional registration or other purposes, recognition requirements may differ depending on the relevant employer, professional body or public authority. Students should check the specific requirements of the organisation or institution concerned rather than assume that the same equivalency procedure applies to every situation. These requirements should also be distinguished from those applying to short professional training courses and non-degree certificates, which are not automatically subject to the same higher education equivalency process.
These national mechanisms take precedence over any international accreditation claim. An accreditation from a foreign or international body does not automatically mean that a qualification will be recognised by Indonesian authorities or employers.
Understanding the different types of quality assurance organisations
Beyond national authorities, learners may encounter several types of organisations in the quality assurance landscape. These organisations differ considerably in their roles, structures and responsibilities, and should not be regarded as interchangeable:
- National agencies and ministries (such as Indonesia’s BAN-PT) carry out official accreditation within their national systems. Their decisions determine formal recognition within the country concerned.
- Independent external quality assurance providers , including QAHE, offer external quality evaluation and accreditation services to institutions in various countries. These are voluntary, institutional-level reviews; they do not substitute for official national accreditation or recognition.
- National quality assurance bodies in other countries , such as the Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education (QAA) in the United Kingdom, conduct quality assurance within their own higher education systems.
- Recognition bodies , such as the Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA) in the United States, primarily recognise accrediting organisations rather than institutions directly.
- Regional networks , such as the Asia-Pacific Quality Network (APQN) and the Arab Network for Quality Assurance in Higher Education (ANQAHE), promote cooperation and the development of quality assurance practices across their regions; they do not accredit individual institutions.
None of these bodies has equivalent authority, and no single accreditation — international or otherwise — guarantees recognition everywhere. What these organisations can usefully provide is public information: lists of reviewed institutions, published standards, and reports that help learners compare providers and understand the claims an institution makes. Consulting more than one credible source generally gives a clearer picture than relying on a single claim.
Practical questions before paying any fees
Families and students can protect themselves by asking a few direct questions:
- Does the institution appear on the official list of recognised providers in its home country?
- For Indonesian learners considering foreign higher education qualifications, what equivalency requirements apply if they intend to continue their studies in Indonesia?
- Can the claimed quality assurance body be contacted, and does it confirm the accreditation or review?
- Will the qualification be accepted by employers or universities in the country where the student intends to work or continue studying?
Providers that hesitate to answer these questions, or that pressure students to enrol immediately, deserve extra caution.
Conclusion
Quality assurance does not guarantee that every graduate will succeed, but it does increase the likelihood that a programme has been designed and delivered with basic standards in mind. As online and professional training options continue to grow, the ability to verify those standards becomes an essential skill. For Indonesian learners, the starting points are clear: check national accreditation status, understand what Ministerial Regulation No. 50 of 2024 says about the certificates a programme can award, and confirm the applicable equivalency requirements for foreign higher education qualifications if they intend to continue their studies in Indonesia. Taking time to check official sources before payment remains the most effective way to choose a programme that offers genuine value.
Prof. Stéphane Narcis is Honorary President and Honorary QA Auditor at the International Association for Quality Assurance in Pre-Tertiary & Higher Education (QAHE). He holds a PhD in Film Studies, a DLitt, and a PDLitt, with further degrees from King’s College London and the University of Winchester. His work spans film and cultural studies, intercultural communication, and quality assurance in education. The views expressed are his own.
